Thursday, June 13, 2013

Higher Real Interest Rates

After  a period of stability, financial markets have become volatile once again, led by major declines in the stock markets of many emerging markets and Japan.  One of the reasons cited is the rise in interest rates (for example, the yield on the ten-year US bond has risen by 0.5% in a short time).  What is the bond market telling us?  By examining the market for TIPS (Treasury Inflation Protected Securities), we can decompose the rise in bond yields into two components: break-even inflation and the real interest rate.  The yield on the TIPS represents the real interest rate (interest rate adjusted for inflation) since investors holding TIPS earn the yield plus are compensated for whatever inflation turns out to be.  Break-even inflation is the difference between the yield on a traditional Treasury and the comparable TIPS.  Some economists use it as a proxy for expected inflation (technically, one must adjust it for the inflation risk premium to obtain the market's expectation of inflation, but we'll save that for another day). 

Why have interest rates risen recently?  An increase in real interest rates.  Here's a chart of the yield on ten-year TIPS (red line) and break-even inflation (green line) over the last 5 years (daily data):

FRED Graph

While break-even inflation has declined recently, you'll notice that, after being negative since late 2011, the real interest rate just turned positive in recent days (and has risen significantly over the last month; from -0.68 at the end of April to 0.21 on June 12).  What's the significance of the change in real interest rates?  Here's an interesting chart of the S&P 500 (blue line) and the real interest rate as estimated by the yield on 10-year TIPS (green line):

FRED Graph

Over the last 5 years, the correlation between the S&P500 and the yield on 10-year TIPS is -0.8; a strong negative relationship.  The most likely explanation for it is low or negative real interest rates motivate investors to seek better returns elsewhere, including the stock market.  Of course there are other factors that are affecting stock prices, but low/negative real interest rates due in part to QE seem to be having a significant impact.  It appears that investors are right to be concerned about impact of the Fed scaling back QE.  Of course, there's still considerable uncertainty as to when will begin to reduce its bond purchases as well as how quickly it'll phase out QE (will it go from $85 billion a month to $0 in a few months or over a much longer period of time).

In the five years before the financial crisis (June 2003-June 2008), the yield on 10-year TIPS averaged 2%.  Though they won't necessarily rise back to that level, if real interest rates continue to normalize (rise somewhat), one can expect continued volatility in financial markets.  It should be noted that the correlation between real interest rates and the stock market prior to the crisis (2003-2008) was small and slightly positive, so once real rates stabilize at a higher level, they should cease being a hindrance to the stock market.

Friday, June 7, 2013

May Employment Report

The headlines from the May employment report are that the unemployment rate rose to 7.6% while the economy added 175,000 jobs (178,000 in the private sector).  But what about the underlying details?  Nothing that dramatic.  The broad measure of unemployment (U6) declined to 13.8% while the labor force participation rate rose to 63.4% (from a 34-year low of 63.3%).  Aggregate hours worked, which had declined in April, rose in May.  All of these numbers are mildly positive.  Where was the job growth?  Food services and drinking places added 38,100 jobs, retail trade added 27,700 and temp agencies added 25,600.  Together, these three sectors represent about 20% of all jobs, but more than half of net job creation in May (and April); they are also relatively low-paying sectors of the economy.  That is one reason why average hourly earnings were flat this month.

What else can we learn from this report?  Since May 2012, the unemployment rate has declined from 8.2% to 7.6%.  However, the unemployment rate rose for teenagers as well as those in their early 20s while the largest declines occurred for those above the age of 55 and those between 25 and 34.  As can be seen in the chart below, the unemployment rate is inversely related to age:


Age
Unemployment Rate
16-19
24.5%
20-24
13.2%
25-34
7.2%
35-44
6.2%
45-54
5.9%
55+
5.3%

What's the key takeaway from the report?  The job market continues to heal at a modest rate, with disproportionate employment growth in relatively low-paying occupations. 

Thursday, May 16, 2013

The Shrinking Budget Deficit

Earlier this week, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released its latest forecast for the budget deficit for 2013 as well as for the next decade.  Depending on one's perspective, there was good news in that the 2013 deficit is now expected to be much lower than previously anticipated, $642 billion or 4% of GDP (down from $1.1 trillion or 7% of GDP in 2012).  Why is it expected to shrink so much?  Revenue is expected to increase by 15% this year due to the payroll tax hike, higher tax rates on the rich, many upper-income people "realized" more income in late 2012 in anticipation of higher tax rates in 2013, and increased payments to the government from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.  Here's a chart of the forecasts for revenue and spending as a percent of GDP:

Total Revenues and Outlays

Not only is the deficit expected to shrink significantly this year, but it is expected to decline to $378 billion or 2.1% of GDP in 2015.  The publicly-held national debt is expected to peak at 76.2% in 2014, fall to a low of 70.8% in 2018 and then begin to rise again.  Does this mean that the budget deficit is no longer a problem?

The CBO also released deficit and debt estimates under an alternative scenario.  Why an alternative scenario?  The CBO must base its forecasts on current law.  That means it must assume that sequestration will continue to be implemented over the next decade, reimbursements to doctors under Medicare will be cut, and some temporary tax provisions will be allowed to expire.  Will this happen?  It's hard to know for sure, but there's a good chance a lot of it won't.  If it doesn't, deficits will be significantly higher (link to excel file with the alternative deficit forecasts).  For example, instead of declining to $378 billion in 2015, the deficit would be $577 billion or 3.3% of GDP (almost $200 billion higher).  The publicly-held national debt would fall to 75% of GDP in 2017 before rising to 83% in 2023 (compared to 74% in the baseline scenario).  Over the decade (2014-2023), the debt would be $2.4 trillion higher under the alternative scenario.

Where does the US stand in terms of the budget deficit and national debt?  The budget deficit is falling.  Of course policies designed to reduce the deficit cause short-term economic pain (tax hikes, sequestration, ...).  Given the progress already achieved in terms of deficit reduction and the continued modest recovery, future efforts should focus on long-term reductions in the deficit (for example, entitlement reform).  The baseline forecast assumes that there will be significant cuts in discretionary spending in the years ahead that may be politically difficult (and may not be the best approach to reduce the deficit).  If these cuts are not implemented, alternative means of controlling future spending will be necessary (further action will be necessary even if most or all of these cuts are implemented).  For further details, see this post from late 2012.

Friday, May 3, 2013

April Employment Report

The government released the April employment report this morning and the big news was upward revisions to job growth in February and March.  Employment in February rose more than any non-Census month since November 2005 (up 332,000) while March employment now is reported to have increased by 138,000 instead of 88,000.  Instead of last month's story about weakness in the job market, it now appears that employment continues to grow at a moderate pace (138,000 in March, 165,000 in April).  Those aren't great numbers, but in line with an economy growing modestly.  The other headline number is that the unemployment rate declined to 7.5%, down from 7.6% in March and the participation rate remained stable, so this was due to a real improvement in the job market (though the participation rate is still at a 34-year low).
What industries contributed most to the gains in employment?  Food and drinking places (restaurants) added about 38,000 in April, temp agencies added 31,000 and retail trade added 29,000.  Add it up and about 60% of the gains were in relatively low-paying industries.  The biggest concern in the report was a decline in the aggregate hours worked, which indicates that many of the jobs created were part time (i.e., fewer total hours worked but more employees means that each employee is working less time).  Two of the industries showing the largest gain in employment, retail trade and leisure/hospitality, are known to have a large proportion of part-time workers.  Using data on average weekly earnings and average hourly earnings (table B-3 of the release), the average worker in retail trade now works about 31.4 hours a week while the average in leisure and hospitality is about 26 hours (both of which declined between March and April).

Even though the economy is adding more jobs than previously estimated (which is definitely good news), the April job report raises questions about the quality of jobs, both in terms of an overabundance of jobs in relatively low-paying industries and a disproportionate number of part-time jobs.

What are the key takeaways?  The economy is adding more jobs than previously thought, but employment is still growing at a modest rate.  Also, the aggregate hours worked has not kept pace with employment growth.  So far this year, employment has increased at a 2.2% annualized rate while aggregate hours worked has risen by only 1.2%.

Friday, April 26, 2013

An Initial Look at First Quarter GDP

The first estimate of first quarter GDP was released this morning and it showed that economic growth was less than the consensus estimate at 2.5% (consensus was about 3%).  The good news was that consumption rose by 3.2%, residential investment rose by 12.6%, and exports rose by 2.9%.  Why was the report weaker than expected?  Business investment rose by only 2.1% and defense spending declined by 11.5% (on top of a 22% decline in the fourth quarter of 2012).  After subtracting from growth at the end of 2012, inventories added about 1% to growth in the first quarter; subtracting inventories from GDP means that final sales rose by 1.5% in the first quarter.

How does this affect the outlook for the rest of the year?  The sluggishness in business investment indicates that businesses remain cautious and may indicate sluggishness in hiring as well (similar to  the March employment report). Though consumer spending grew at a quicker pace than any time since the end of 2010, it's unlikely to continue at that pace, given the expiration of the payroll tax cut at the beginning of this year (other data suggests that it started to hurt consumer spending late in the first quarter and that weakness will show up in the second quarter numbers).  On a more positive note, residential investment remains strong and is likely to continue to be the strongest point of the economy for the rest of 2013.  Also, it's unlikely that defense spending will continue to fall as quickly and thus will cease to be a drag on growth.

What's the key takeaways?  More of the same, but for different reasons.  The economy is likely to continue to grow at a modest pace, close to 2%.  Consumer spending will constrained by the reduction in disposable income resulting from the increase in the payroll tax.  Business investment, after rebounding strongly in 2010-2011, has grown modestly over the last year and is likely to continue on that path.  It looks like 2013 will be another year of slow recovery with modest economic growth.

Thursday, April 25, 2013

Progress in Consumer Deleveraging and Housing: How Far We've Come

During the depths of the financial crisis, a few charts made it clear that consumers needed to deleverage and housing prices had to come down considerably from bubble levels.  I thought it would be helpful to see how much progress has been made in recent years to get a better idea as to how much further the economy has to go to correct the excesses of the early- to mid-2000s.

The first chart is the Case-Shiller Home Price index from 1890-2012, which shows a housing price index adjusted for inflation:

Case Shiller Home Price Index Chart

After moving between 60 and 140 for a century, the index spiked to 220 in late 2005, clearly indicating the existence of a housing bubble.  As of late 2012, the index was down to 134.5 and appeared to be stabilizing (even increasing somewhat).  Though this is still a little high by historical standards, it is in line with the performance since WW2.

The second chart is the ratio of consumer debt (credit market debt) to disposable income from the early 1950s to the present:

ALFRED Graph

 As can be seen, there was an upward trend over time, but the ratio jumped during the 2000s, rising from about 90% at the start of the century to 130% in the summer of 2007.   Consumer deleveraging was essential to return to historical trends.  As of the end of 2012, it was down to 105%.  Though there's not a magic number that indicates deleveraging is complete, much progress has been made and it appears that it is now closer to the upward trend from the late 1980s to 2000.  Of course the upward trend from the 1980s and 1990s was probably not sustainable (otherwise the ratio would continue to rise indefinitely).  Whether the ratio should be 105% or 100% or..., it appears that most of the deleveraging has already taken place.

Though there are other indicators to consider, it appears that some of the excesses of the bubble era have been corrected, returning closer to historical norms.

Sunday, April 21, 2013

Some Thoughts on the Employment Report for Florida and Metro Orlando

The latest information about the job market in Florida and Orlando was released on Friday.  The headline numbers looked good: Florida added nearly 33,000 jobs in March and the unemployment rate fell to 7.5% while the unemployment rate in Orlando declined to 6.6% with employment rising by 3500 (metro data are not seasonally adjusted).  Of course it's important to look at the details.

The entire decline in the unemployment rate for Florida was due to a decline in the labor force participation rate, which fell from 60.5% to 60.3%.  If the participation had remained constant, the unemployment rate would be 7.8%.  In terms of nonfarm payrolls (employment), nearly a third of the jobs were in accommodations and food services.  However, a sizeable portion was also in construction, which was the fastest growing sector of the economy.  Add it up and it was a pretty good report for Florida.

The decline in Orlando's unemployment rate was due in part to a somewhat strong job market, but a significant portion resulted from seasonal factors and a decline in the labor force participation rate.  What really stood out was that over 90% of the job growth in March was due to leisure and hospitality (3200 out of 3500); that sector also accounted for over 60% of employment growth over the last 12 months.  The high concentration of job growth in one sector and the fact that leisure/hospitality jobs have lower pay than most other sectors raises questions about the strength of the Orlando economy.  So there's a mixed picture for metro Orlando: a sizeable decline in the unemployment rate, but employment growth concentrated in one of the lowest paying sectors.  One other item to note is that construction employment declined in March as well as over the last 12 months, which does not seem to fit with the anecdotal evidence of increasing construction activity.

What are the key takeaways?  Job growth in Florida is outpacing that of the nation over the last year, though Orlando is coming up short (1.9% growth for Florida, 1.4% for the US, and 1.3% for Orlando).  Given cutbacks in government employment, private sector employment growth is stronger (2.4% for Florida, 1.6% for Orlando).  Florida's labor market continues to improve, but similar to the nation, a declining participation rate is contributing to the declining unemployment rate.  Orlando's job market also is improving, but there are concerns about the quality of jobs as well as growth being concentrated in one sector rather than broad-based gains.