Thursday, August 22, 2013

More on Part-Time vs. Full-Time Employment

In my discussion of the July jobs report, I noted that, according to the government's household survey, 77% of net job creation in 2013 has been in terms of part-time jobs.  The data on part-time employment tends to be volatile, so I decided to look at the long-term trend.  The following chart shows the proportion of part-time jobs in the economy (note: there was a break in the data in 1994, not a surge in part-time employment)

ALFRED Graph

After rising during the 1970s, the percentage of part-time employment tended to be cyclical, rising during recessions and falling during expansions.  It was 17% in 1980 and, after nearly three decades of ups and downs, it was 17% at the start of the Great Recession.  As during previous recessions, it rose from 2007 to 2009, reaching a high of 20% (the largest increase since records started being kept in 1968).  After declining modestly through the end of 2012, it has risen back to 19.6% as of July 2013.
It remains to be seen whether it rises a little more, stabilizes near its current rate, or resumes a slow decline over time.  Regardless, it appears that it will take a long time to return to 17% (if ever).  Why the increase in the ratio of part-time employment?  Regardless which side you take in terms of the relative role of  the weak recovery vs. Obamacare, increasing the cost of full-time employment relative to part-time employment can't help but encourage a greater reliance on part-time jobs.


Saturday, August 3, 2013

July Job Market

Way too much going on recently to post to the blog, but now there's too many things to discuss.  Yesterday, the government released the July employment report and though it showed a decline in the unemployment rate to 7.4%, the underlying details were quite weak.  The headline number indicated that only 162,000 were added, which was less than expected (and gains from previous months were revised downward).  What type of jobs were created?  Retail trade added 46,800 while food and drinkings place added 38,400 (together accounting for a majority of the net jobs created).  That's just for July; what about for 2013 as a whole? Thus far, the economy has added 1.347 million jobs this year, 187,000 of which were in retail trade and 246,500 in food and drinking places.  While these two sectors accounted for 18.5% of all jobs at the start of the year, they account for about one-third of net job creation in 2013 (food and drinking places in particular represented 7.5% of jobs at the beginning of the year, yet was the source of nearly one-in-five new jobs so far in 2013).

According to the household survey, part-time employment accounted for about two-thirds of the jobs created in July.  So far in 2013, part-time employment accounts for 77% of net job creation (note: 20% of all jobs were part time at the beginning of the year).  Since the start of the recession in December 2007, the economy has lost 5.5 million full-time jobs while adding about 3.5 million part-time jobs.  The relative importance of part-time employment helps to explain why total hours worked declined in July even though employment increased (note: this isn't the average work week, but an estimate of total hours worked throughout the economy).

Many economists have been trying to reconcile the relatively weak estimates for economic growth with the comparably stronger numbers for employment.  The underlying details of the employment report suggest that both measures of the state of the economy reveal an economy growing modestly (to use the Fed's latest description).

Friday, July 5, 2013

June Employment Report

The headlines of the June employment report are that the economy added 195,000 jobs and the unemployment report remained at 7.6%.  Beneath the surface, the report is generally good (by today's standards!).  Revisions show an extra 70,000 jobs created in April and May than previously estimated (employment is now up 2.3 million over the last 12 months).  Also, the participation rate rose slightly to 63.5%.  Average weekly wages rose by 0.4% (strong for one month) and is up 2.2% over the last year (not as strong, but OK).  Which industry added the most jobs?  Food services and drinking places added nearly 52,000 in June and almost 100,000 over the last two months.  Other industries adding jobs include "amusement, gambling, and recreation," which added about 19,000 jobs in June and over 40,000 in the last two months.  Housing and auto-related industries (construction, auto manufacturing, retailers related to housing and autos, ...) added just over 35,000 jobs.  Local government employment (other than education) rose by 15,000 and is now up by more than 25,000 since June 2012.

What are the negatives in the report?  The broad measure of unemployment (U6) rose from 13.8% to 14.3% (the largest increase since Spring 2009) due to a surge in the number of people working part time for economic reasons.  Both figures reversed declines from earlier this year.  The number of people working part time for economic reasons are now higher than a year ago while U6 is close to where it was at the beginning of the year (and last Fall).  Also, as noted earlier, a disproportionate number of jobs are in relatively low paying industries, such as food services and drinking places, though less than in prior months.

What are the key takeaways?  The job market is relatively strong (OK by historical standards, but strong compared to recent history), adding just under 200,000 jobs a month for the last 3 months (many in low-paying industries).  This contrasts with economic growth, which has been quite weak in the last 9 months (0.4% in 2012Q4, 1.8% in 2013Q1, and forecasted to be around 1.5% in 2013Q2).  How are financial markets reacting to the new data?  As of 9am Friday morning, ten-year bond yields are now about 2.7%, the highest since July 2011, reflecting in part concerns as to how a strengthening job market will affect the Fed's timetable in tapering QE3.

Saturday, June 29, 2013

Some thoughts on the Fed, QE3, and Financial Markets

Let's take a look back at some of the economic news from this week.  First, in response to some turmoil in financial markets, several members of the FOMC tried to clarify the remarks Ben Bernanke made following the Fed's most recent meeting while some commentators complained that Bernanke was not clear and the Fed had a communication problem.  Fed members said what Bernanke meant was that the Fed plans to begin reducing QE3 (tapering) once the economy strengthens further, using a 7% unemployment rate as a guidepost.  Tapering isn't immediate, but would probably begin later this year, assuming Fed forecasts turn out to be correct, and QE3 will completely end next year.  They emphasized that it's data dependent, so if the economy is weaker than expected, QE3 would continue for a longer period of time.  They also emphasized that tapering shouldn't be confused with an increase in the federal funds rate, which is unlikely until 2015.  How does this differ from what Bernanke said (see previous post)?  What he said was basically:

The Fed plans to begin reducing QE3 (tapering) once the economy strengthens further, using a 7% unemployment rate as a guidepost.  Tapering isn't immediate, but would probably begin later this year, assuming Fed forecasts turn out to be correct, and be QE3 would completely end next year.  It's data dependent, so if the economy is weaker than expected, QE3 would continue for a longer period of time.  Tapering shouldn't be confused with an increase in the federal funds rate, which is unlikely until 2015.
 
If you can't tell the difference, that's OK; they just repeated what Bernanke had already said.  From my perspective, it was hard to misinterpret Bernanke (there must have been some hidden signal; saying that rates would rise in 2015 probably meant 2014, ...).  Why didn't the Fed just say tapering would begin in September (or December) and QE3 would end in June 2014?  Because QE3 is designed to strengthen the economy and reduce unemployment.  If it needs to be in place a little longer to achieve the goal, it'll be extended (tapering beginning in 2014 instead of late 2013, etc.).  So making tapering of QE3 dependent on the state of the economy makes perfect sense.  As a reminder, I'm a skeptic of QE3 (see here and here), so I'm not defending the policy.

So why did markets react they way they did to Bernanke's hints in May and his remarks following the most recent Fed meeting?  First, let me point you to a post prior to the Fed's meeting about rising real interest rates.  Since QE3 involves Fed purchases of bonds, some investors thought it would be a good idea to buy the bonds before the Fed did (since demand from the Fed would increase bond prices, it makes sense to buy the bonds first so you can benefit from the price increase).  Also, negative real interest rates caused many investors to seek better returns in riskier assets.  Once the reality sunk in that QE3 wouldn't go on forever and interest rates started to increase, these trades reversed.  As a result, interest rates spiked and asset prices declined, particularly on riskier assets such as emerging markets.  I don't think this represented investors thinking that the Fed going to end QE3 immediately or increase the federal funds rate soon, but instead represented the unwinding of speculation.  There's a lot less speculative excesses in financial markets now compared to a month ago, which is a good thing for the future (makes new bubbles less likely). 

What is the likely impact of the spike in interest rates on the economy?  That will be addressed in a future post.  What's the key takeaway from what's happened in financial markets in recent weeks?  In an era of record low interest rates (near zero on safe assets), many investors took on greater risk than they would normally prefer in order to achieve a higher return.  The reality of QE3 ending at some point in the foreseeable future along with the subsequent increase in real interest rates caused investors to better appreciate the riskiness of their investments, which is a good thing over time (though it may hurt in the short run).

Friday, June 21, 2013

May Employment Report: Florida and Orlando

The latest report about the job market in Florida and its localities was released this morning.  The headlines are that the unemployment rate for Florida is 7.1%, the lowest since September 2008.  Is the job market as good as it was back then?  Not quite.  Though progress has been made in recent years, we are still a long way from 2008.  Florida is still down 137,000 jobs since September 2008 and has about 550,000 fewer jobs than before the recession.  How has the unemployment rate declined so much even though employment is still lagging?  The labor force participation rate has declined from about 64% before the recession to 60.3% in May 2013.  Thus, most of the decline in the unemployment rate in recent years has been due to a smaller percentage of people participating in the job market.

What sectors have experienced the strongest employment growth in the last year?  Interest-sensitive sectors - housing and autos.  Areas with the fastest employment growth include construction, auto dealers, building supply stores, and real estate.  In terms of absolute numbers, food and drinking places added the most jobs statewide over the last year, up 26,700.  What about the most recent month?  Florida actually lost jobs, mainly due to a decline on construction, which gave back some of its recent gains.

Unlike statewide, the data released today for metropolitan areas were not seasonally adjusted.  Orlando showed no change in employment while the unemployment rate ticked up a little, to 6.6%.  The seasonally-adjusted unemployment rate will be released in a few weeks and will likely indicate little change in the unemployment rate (close to 6.9%; this estimate is based on historical seasonal adjustments).  Over the last year, a majority of the jobs created locally have been in leisure and hospitality (8500 out of 16,800), led by food and drinking places, the fastest growing category over the last 12 months (up 6%).

What are the key takeaways from today's report?  The Florida economy continues to heal, but employment growth remains modest.  The rate of employment growth in Orlando, Florida and the United States were roughly equal at about 1.6 to 1.7% over the last year.

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

The Fed's Latest Announcement Regarding the Direction of Monetary Policy

As expected, the Fed announced this afternoon that it will continue QE3 without tapering, for now.  In addition, it released its latest forecasts for the economy.  What are the headlines?  During the press conference following the announcement, Ben Bernanke said that, if the Fed forecast turns out to be correct, the Fed will probably begin tapering its purchases of bonds later this year and end QE3 by mid-2014.  Also, a large majority of FOMC participants anticipate the federal funds rate beginning to increase in 2015.  The initial response of the market has been a sharp decline in stocks and a significant increase in interest rates with the ten-year bond rising to 2.33%, the highest since March 2012.

Let's take a closer look at the Fed's view of the economy.  First, it should be noted that the projections are those of each of the 12 district banks, not the Federal Reserve itself (i.e., not the Board of Governors or Ben Bernanke).  The table below show the central tendency of the forecasts, which is the range of forecasts after eliminating the 3 highest and 3 lowest forecasts for each variable. 
 
 
2013
2014
2015
Economic growth
2.3 to 2.6%
3 to 3.5%
2.9 to 3.6%
Unemployment rate
7.2 to 7.3%
6.5 to 6.8%
5.8 to 6.2%
inflation
0.8 to 1.2%
1.4 to 2%
1.6 to 2%
note: the forecast for the unemployment rate is for the end of the year

In addition to the forecasts, the Fed noted that it thinks the downside risks to the economy have subsided (less risk of a slowdown).  The forecast for economic growth for all 3 years is somewhat more optimistic than that of most private forecasts, but the other forecasts are in line with other forecasts.  What are the implications for monetary policy?  The Fed has announced thresholds (their word, not mine) for inflation (forecast above 2.5%, 1-2 years in the future; it relies on a forecast of inflation since it takes time for monetary policy to impact inflation) and the unemployment rate (6.5%) for when they are likely to consider increasing the federal funds rate.  Today, Ben Bernanke suggested that QE3 would likely end as the unemployment rate reached 7%.  Given that the Fed expects the unemployment rate to reach 7% in Spring/Summer 2014, QE3 will likely end around that time (if their forecast is correct).  Since it will preceded by a gradual reduction in bond purchases, the tapering will likely begin in late 2013.  Ben Bernanke emphasized that if the data shows a slower economy (including a higher than expected unemployment rate), QE3 could be extended further into 2014 (and thus tapering may not start until sometime in 2014).

What are the key takeaways from the latest news from the Fed?  It is more confident about the strength of the economy, but still thinks it requires stimulus.  In addition, it provided some clarification as to when it would begin to taper and eventually end QE3, though the exact timing is dependent on the data.  As of now, it expects that tapering will begin later this year with QE3 coming to an end by this time next year.

Monday, June 17, 2013

Recent Trends in Income for Florida and Orlando

Last week, the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) released the latest estimates for state and metropolitan personal income (overall and per capita; both figures in real terms; i.e., adjusted for inflation).  I exchanged a series of emails with a reporter from the Orlando Sentinel, but only a very small portion was included in the story, so I decided to include more of the details in this post.

After declining by nearly 7% in 2009, real personal income in Florida is recovering (up 3.7% in 2010 and 2.2% in 2011, the latest year for which data are available). As of 2011, it was still below where it had been in 2007. Likewise, real personal income per capita (i.e., real personal income divided by population, not the same as income per worker) is slowly recovering from a steep decline in 2009 (down 7.5% in 2009, up 2.7% and 1% in 2010 and 2011, respectively). As of 2011, it was still down just over 5% from 2007. Inflation in Florida was slightly lower than the US as a whole, averaging 1.6% from 2007-2011 compared to 1.9% for the US.

The performance of Metro Orlando mirrored that of the state as real personal income rose 3.4% and 2.7% in 2010 and 2011, respectively, while real personal income per capita rose by 2.1% and 1.2%. The ratio of real personal income per capita in Orlando compared to the nation as a whole remained steady from 2009-2011 at about 87%.

How does Orlando compare to other metropolitan areas in Florida?  Here's a table comparing some of the metropolitan areas in Florida.

  Per capita Income by Metropolitan Area: overall and by Type for 2011
 
Jacksonville
Miami
Orlando
Tampa
Personal income
$40,709
$43,072
$35,535
$39,261
Personal income from earnings from work by place of residence
$25,837
$24,543
$22,969
$22,201
Dividends, Interest, and Rent
$7,712
$10,601
$5,695
$8,810
Current Transfers
$7,160
$7,928
$6,872
$8,249
note: add rows 2-4 to get row 1; data are not inflation adjusted

The headline number shows Orlando lagging behind other metro areas, but the reason is somewhat surprising.  While earnings explain some of the underperformance, the major reason is weakness in dividends, interest, and rental income.  For example, while earnings per capita are higher in Orlando than Tampa, personal income per capita is 10% higher in Tampa due to higher dividends/interest/rent and higher transfer payments.  Earnings in Orlando also lag behind Jacksonville and Miami, but once again, the other forms of income, particularly dividend/interest/rent, play a more significant role.

What explains the relatively low level of dividends/interest/rent in Orlando?  One possible reason is a smaller amount of wealth due in part to a younger population.  The median age in Orlando is 33 compared to 39 in Miami and 35 in both Jacksonville and Tampa (different sources provide slightly different estimates).  Other factors also play a role, but that's a subject for another day.

What are the key takeaways?  Income in Florida is slowly recovered from the damage suffered during the Great Recession.  Also, differences in per capita income reflect not only differences in earnings but also in unearned income, including income from wealth and government transfer payments.