Showing posts with label gdp. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gdp. Show all posts
Thursday, May 29, 2014
Revisions to First Quarter GDP
The headline number for this morning's GDP report was that the economy shrank by 1% (compared to an initial estimate of growth of 0.1%). What was responsible for the revision? Almost the entire revision was due to a decline in inventory investment, which subtracted 1.6% from economic growth compared to an initial estimate of 0.6%. So final sales (growth excluding inventories) declined from 0.7% to 0.6%. This is actually good news for future growth since companies have less inventory on hand, increases in demand are more likely to result in increases in production. Most of the other details of the report are similar to initial estimates (see previous post) - positives include a record contribution from healthcare due to Obamacare and a sizeable contribution from utilities due to the harsh winter while minuses include weak construction (likely due to the harsh winter) and weakness in business investment and exports (some payback from unsustainably strong exports in late 2013).
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
First Quarter GDP
The economy barely grew in the first quarter of 2014 (+0.1%). Though this was below the consensus estimate, many of the reasons for the slowdown were not a surprise. The inventory buildup in 2013 was pared down somewhat resulting in inventories subtracting almost 0.6% from economic growth. Exports rose at an unsustainable rate in late 2013, given the state of the global economy. Some of this gain was given back as exports fell in early 2014. As a result, net exports subtracted 0.8% from economic growth. Of course everyone is aware of the severe winter and how that hurt economic growth (though that is difficult to quantify). Let's look at some of the details.
At first glance, what stood out to me was the growth in consumption led by a significant increase in spending on consumer services - the largest since 2000. One of the main reasons was a surge in spending on health care (+9.9%), the largest quarterly increase since 1980. Health care spending rarely increases by more than 5% (just over 10% of the time since 1980), so an increase of nearly10% is extremely high. In fact, spending on healthcare services added 1.1% to economic growth, the largest contribution since records started to be kept in 1959 (it only exceeded 0.6% one other time). Why would healthcare spending increase so much? The Affordable Care Act or Obamacare. Also, due to the harsh winter, spending on housing and utitities increased by the second highest rate in the last 25 years, adding 0.7% to economic growth. On the flip side, business purchases of computers and peripheral equipment declined at the fastest rate since 1982, contributing to a decline in overall business investment.
What are the key takeaways from the report? There were a lot of temporary factors affecting the data, so interpretation needs to be careful. The biggest disappointment was the weakness in business spending, particularly on equipment. Watch to see how this performs in the coming months to see whether the economy continues to grow at a modest pace or begins to accelerate.
Thursday, January 30, 2014
Fourth Quarter GDP
The government released its first estimate of GDP for the fourth quarter of 2013 this morning, showing 3.2% growth for the quarter and 2.7% compared to the fourth quarter of 2012. The details were generally good, but some don't look sustainable. Good news included consumer spending rising by 3.3%, it's fastest rate since the end of 2010. On the flip side, residential investment fell at nearly a 10% rate, it's first decline since the summer of 2010. Though residential construction may not grow as quickly in the coming year (compared to the double-digit growth seen in recent years, this was probably an aberration due to weather). Business investment grew by just under 4%, somewhat slower than the middle of the year due to a decline in business construction). The private domestic economy (consumers and businesses) grew by 2.4% in the fourth quarter compared to 2.25% in the third and 2.2% in the second (i.e., growth has been relatively stable, but increasing slightly).
Exports added 1.5% to economic growth, the second strongest contribution since the end of the recession. Given the state of the global economy, this is unlikely to be repeated (exports may do fine, but are unlikely to grow as rapidly as at the end of 2013). Federal government purchases fell by 12.6% due to both cuts in defense spending as well as nondefense spending (as a result of the government shutdown). Given the recent passage of the budget covering the next couple of years, this is unlikely to be repeated. After adding about 1.7% to economic growth in the third quarter, inventories added 0.4% to growth in the fourth quarter. Though inventories have added to economic growth throughout 2013, that's unlikely to be repeated in 2014.
What does this report tell us about the economy? First, you'll note that the analysis keeps using the phrase. "this is unlikely to be repeated." Exports and inventories are unlikely to add as much to economic growth in 2014 while residential investment and government purchases are unlikely to subtract as much from growth as they did at the end of 2013. So what's the likely direction of economic growth? Though some consumers still face headwinds (student loan debt, modest growth in incomes, ...), it appears that much of the deleveraging as a result of the financial crisis is over. As such, consumer spending will pick up compared to recent years. Combine this with moderate growth in business investment and you get economic growth approaching 3% in 2014. If the US does grow by 3%, it'll be the fastest pace of economic growth since 2005.
Exports added 1.5% to economic growth, the second strongest contribution since the end of the recession. Given the state of the global economy, this is unlikely to be repeated (exports may do fine, but are unlikely to grow as rapidly as at the end of 2013). Federal government purchases fell by 12.6% due to both cuts in defense spending as well as nondefense spending (as a result of the government shutdown). Given the recent passage of the budget covering the next couple of years, this is unlikely to be repeated. After adding about 1.7% to economic growth in the third quarter, inventories added 0.4% to growth in the fourth quarter. Though inventories have added to economic growth throughout 2013, that's unlikely to be repeated in 2014.
What does this report tell us about the economy? First, you'll note that the analysis keeps using the phrase. "this is unlikely to be repeated." Exports and inventories are unlikely to add as much to economic growth in 2014 while residential investment and government purchases are unlikely to subtract as much from growth as they did at the end of 2013. So what's the likely direction of economic growth? Though some consumers still face headwinds (student loan debt, modest growth in incomes, ...), it appears that much of the deleveraging as a result of the financial crisis is over. As such, consumer spending will pick up compared to recent years. Combine this with moderate growth in business investment and you get economic growth approaching 3% in 2014. If the US does grow by 3%, it'll be the fastest pace of economic growth since 2005.
Tuesday, December 10, 2013
The Latest Economic Reports: GDP and Employment
The government released two economic reports last week which, on the surface, indicates that the economy was strengthening in the second half of 2013. Of course there's more to it than that. Economic growth for the third quarter was revised up to 3.6% (from an initial report of 2.8%). Does that mean growth and demand were picking up? Not quite. About half of the growth for the quarter was due to an increase in inventories; final sales rose by 1.9% (in line with the previous trend). In fact, both consumer spending and business investment increased at a slower rate in the third quarter compared to the second quarter. This was offset somewhat by somewhat faster growth in state/local government spending. Also, another measure of economic growth, gross domestic income, rose by 1.4% in the third quarter (after growing more quickly than GDP in recent quarters). What does this mean? More of the same. The recent trend in economic growth has been about 2%.
The other major economic news was the November Employment report, which showed an increase of 203,000 jobs with the unemployment rate falling to 7%. Is this good news? Yes, but not as good as it appears on the surface. If you have read this blog before, you probably know what's coming next. The main reason for the decline in the unemployment rate in recent months (and recent years) is the decline in the participation rate (a smaller portion of the population participating in the job market). The participation rate fell from 63.2% in September to 63% in November (was 62.8% in October). If it had remained at 63.2%, the unemployment rate would have been 7.3% in November (a slight increase rather than a decline of 0.2%). The quality of the jobs added appeared to improve somewhat in November compared to previous months, with a higher portion of jobs in relatively high-paying industries such as construction and manufacturing and a smaller share in relatively low-paying industries compared to previous months.
Together, the two reports suggest that the economy continues to grow at a modest pace: an underlying growth rate of 2% with about 200,000 jobs per month.
The other major economic news was the November Employment report, which showed an increase of 203,000 jobs with the unemployment rate falling to 7%. Is this good news? Yes, but not as good as it appears on the surface. If you have read this blog before, you probably know what's coming next. The main reason for the decline in the unemployment rate in recent months (and recent years) is the decline in the participation rate (a smaller portion of the population participating in the job market). The participation rate fell from 63.2% in September to 63% in November (was 62.8% in October). If it had remained at 63.2%, the unemployment rate would have been 7.3% in November (a slight increase rather than a decline of 0.2%). The quality of the jobs added appeared to improve somewhat in November compared to previous months, with a higher portion of jobs in relatively high-paying industries such as construction and manufacturing and a smaller share in relatively low-paying industries compared to previous months.
Together, the two reports suggest that the economy continues to grow at a modest pace: an underlying growth rate of 2% with about 200,000 jobs per month.
Friday, October 26, 2012
Third Quarter GDP Report
The government released its initial estimate of GDP for the third quarter and it came in slightly higher than expected at a 2% annualized growth rate (compared to 1.3% in the second quarter and 2% in the first quarter). Consumer spending rose by 2%, federal government spending (led by defense) rose by 9.6%, and residential investment rose by 14.4%. On the downside, business investment declined by 1.3% and exports fell by 1.6%. The primary contributors to the faster growth were government spending (went from subtracting 0.1% from growth in the second quarter to adding 0.7% in the third quarter) and consumer spending which added 1.4% to growth in the third quarter compared to 1.1% in the second quarter.
What does the report suggest about the strength of the private sector? Here's a chart of final private demand over the last 5 years (includes consumption, fixed investment (not inventories), and net exports):
A major reason for this slowdown is the weakness of business investment in equipment and software:
After growing at about a 10% rate in 2010 and 2011 and 5% in the first half of 2012, investment in equipment and software was flat (tiny negative) in the third quarter, the weakest performance since the Spring of 2009 (at the end of the recession). In addition, exports declined for the first time since the first quarter of 2009, reflecting the global economic slowdown.
What's the takeaway? The economy continues to struggle, still growing but at a low rate with some signs of increasing weakness in the private sector.
What does the report suggest about the strength of the private sector? Here's a chart of final private demand over the last 5 years (includes consumption, fixed investment (not inventories), and net exports):
After posting a gain of 3% in the first quarter of 2012, the growth rate of private demand has declined to 1.9% in the second quarter and 1.4% in the third quarter (the lowest growth since the summer of 2010). Thus, while the the headline number showed slightly faster growth, the underlying strength of the private sector seems to be slipping.A major reason for this slowdown is the weakness of business investment in equipment and software:
After growing at about a 10% rate in 2010 and 2011 and 5% in the first half of 2012, investment in equipment and software was flat (tiny negative) in the third quarter, the weakest performance since the Spring of 2009 (at the end of the recession). In addition, exports declined for the first time since the first quarter of 2009, reflecting the global economic slowdown.
What's the takeaway? The economy continues to struggle, still growing but at a low rate with some signs of increasing weakness in the private sector.
Labels:
economic growth,
gdp
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
GDP and the Income/Spending Report
It's time to catch up on recent reports about the economy. Last Friday's GDP report was somewhat surprising, given the composition of economic growth. While consumption rose moderately (somewhat high by current standards), business investment actually declined. This was likely due to policy issues as some companies moved investment into the fourth quarter of 2011 to take advantage of expiring tax breaks. But even with that, investment growth over the last 2 quarters was lower than any time since the Winter of 2009-10. Investment in equipment grew at an annualized rate of 4.5% over the last 6 months compared to nearly 11% in the previous 6 months. After surging in the Spring and Summer of 2011, investment in structures has declined by about 6.5% in the Fall and Winter (seasonally adjusted, annualized rate). Together, this suggests that the bounceback in investment following the end of the recession is over and firms are now basing their investment decisions on expected economic conditions.
Meanwhile, though consumption was a strong point in the GDP report, the income/spending report released on Monday indicates that consumer spending was slowing down as the first quarter came to an end. After increasing at an annualized rate of nearly 5% in January and February, growth in real consumer spending slowed to just over a 1% rate in March. At the same time, real disposable income was flat for the quarter, resulting in a lower savings rate (i.e., more spending with flat income results in less savings). This implies that unless income starts to increases more quickly, consumer spending should slow down in the coming months.
Given a slowdown in investment growth and slower, but moderate growth in consumer spending, economic growth should remain moderate through the rest of 2012 (barring some external shock, such as from Spain). As discussed elsewhere, moderate economic growth means that employment growth should also moderate, as already seen in the March employment report. This doesn't mean that the economy is going to worsen, but that it should continue to grow at a modest pace.
Meanwhile, though consumption was a strong point in the GDP report, the income/spending report released on Monday indicates that consumer spending was slowing down as the first quarter came to an end. After increasing at an annualized rate of nearly 5% in January and February, growth in real consumer spending slowed to just over a 1% rate in March. At the same time, real disposable income was flat for the quarter, resulting in a lower savings rate (i.e., more spending with flat income results in less savings). This implies that unless income starts to increases more quickly, consumer spending should slow down in the coming months.
Given a slowdown in investment growth and slower, but moderate growth in consumer spending, economic growth should remain moderate through the rest of 2012 (barring some external shock, such as from Spain). As discussed elsewhere, moderate economic growth means that employment growth should also moderate, as already seen in the March employment report. This doesn't mean that the economy is going to worsen, but that it should continue to grow at a modest pace.
Labels:
consumer spending,
disposable income,
economic growth,
gdp
Thursday, March 8, 2012
GDP: Small Business vs. Large Business
A story about how the small business share of GDP declined below 45% in 2010 caught my attention, so I decided to explore it further. Here's a link to the report behind the headlines. First, it should be noted that the report defines a small business as a company with fewer than 500 employees (so large businesses are those with 500 or more employees). There's quite a bit of interesting information available. For example, here's a chart showing nominal economic growth for small businesses vs. large businesses since 2003 (the classification system changed in 2003, so it represents a good starting point):
Why the underperformance of smal businesses? One reason is construction, which represents about 10% of small business GDP, but only 2% of large business GDP. In addition, in several sectors, large businesses outperformed small businesses. For example, manufacturing suffered a significant decline in 2009 regardless of the size of the firm, but large business manufacturing declined by 6.4% while small business manufacturing declined by 15.5%. As manufacturing rebounded in 2010, large businesses grew by 6.9% while small businesses grew by 4%. Similarly, in wholesale and retail trade, small businesses declined at nearly three times the rate of large businesses in 2008-2009.
Which sectors are dominated by small businesses in terms of share of GDP? Construction (83%), Real Estate & Leasing (75%), and Arts & Entertainment (69%). Large Businesses dominate Utilities (nearly 90%), Information Services (88%), and Manufacturing (72%). Just over 13% of small business GDP comes from Wholesale & Retail Trade while just over 12% comes from Real Estate/Leasing and Professional/Technical Services, respectively. As of 2010, the largest shares of large business GDP are derived from Manufacturing (21%), Finance (15.6%), and Wholesale/Retail Trade (14%).
For the period as a whole, the nominal growth of large business GDP grew by 46% while small business GDP grew by 26%. You'll note the rapid growth of large business GDP in 2010; nearly 60% of the growth was due to one sector - finance (this was not a rebound from the crash but represented nearly a 30% increase from the previous peak).
Why the underperformance of smal businesses? One reason is construction, which represents about 10% of small business GDP, but only 2% of large business GDP. In addition, in several sectors, large businesses outperformed small businesses. For example, manufacturing suffered a significant decline in 2009 regardless of the size of the firm, but large business manufacturing declined by 6.4% while small business manufacturing declined by 15.5%. As manufacturing rebounded in 2010, large businesses grew by 6.9% while small businesses grew by 4%. Similarly, in wholesale and retail trade, small businesses declined at nearly three times the rate of large businesses in 2008-2009.
Which sectors are dominated by small businesses in terms of share of GDP? Construction (83%), Real Estate & Leasing (75%), and Arts & Entertainment (69%). Large Businesses dominate Utilities (nearly 90%), Information Services (88%), and Manufacturing (72%). Just over 13% of small business GDP comes from Wholesale & Retail Trade while just over 12% comes from Real Estate/Leasing and Professional/Technical Services, respectively. As of 2010, the largest shares of large business GDP are derived from Manufacturing (21%), Finance (15.6%), and Wholesale/Retail Trade (14%).
There's much more information available in the report. It confirms what most people already knew; small businesses are struggling as the economy continues to recover from the Great Recession.
Labels:
gdp,
small business
Friday, January 27, 2012
Fourth Quarter GDP
This morning's report on fourth quarter GDP was a little disappointing, showing economic growth of 2.8%, which was below expectations. Growth in personal consumption, the largest portion of the economy, grew at a 2% annual rate, which was in line with recent trends and didn't reflect the burst that some were expecting. Spending on motor vehicles did surge, but spending on services was relatively flat. Federal spending subtracted from GDP, led by a significant decline in defense spending (mainly reflecting the timing of purchases). On a cautionary note for future economic growth, inventories were responsible for just under 2% of economic growth; thus final sales to domestic producers rose by only 0.9%. In other words, when one removes the effect of a build-up of inventories, economic growth was under 1%. The build-up in inventories suggests that future production will be constrained.
After rising to above 6% during the recession, the savings rate has declined to 3.7%, the lowest since 2007. One reason is that real disposable income per capita was flat for the quarter and down for the year. This raises concerns about consumer spending as we move into 2012. On a more positive note, inflation as measured by the PCE deflator rose only 0.7%, the lowest since Spring 2010, reflecting a slowdown in inflation.
Overall, a weaker than expected report that continues to confirm a modest economic recovery without evidence of speeding up any time soon.
After rising to above 6% during the recession, the savings rate has declined to 3.7%, the lowest since 2007. One reason is that real disposable income per capita was flat for the quarter and down for the year. This raises concerns about consumer spending as we move into 2012. On a more positive note, inflation as measured by the PCE deflator rose only 0.7%, the lowest since Spring 2010, reflecting a slowdown in inflation.
Overall, a weaker than expected report that continues to confirm a modest economic recovery without evidence of speeding up any time soon.
Labels:
economic growth,
gdp
Tuesday, November 22, 2011
Latest Report on GDP
This morning's GDP report surprised on the downside. Instead of growth of 2.5% in Q3, it's now estimated to have grown by 2%. The good news is that the primary reason for the downward revision was slower growth in inventories, which subtracted 1.5% from economic growth. This suggests that firms are being cautious in terms of inventory management, reducing the likelihood of future cutbacks in production (and increasing the chance of slightly stronger growth in Q4). Typically, one cause of recessions is companies having excess inventories that they need to reduce to get them back in line with sales. Of course the weak growth in Q3 confirms that the economy was continuing to struggle heading into the end of the year. After being propped up in Q1 by the payroll tax cut, disposable income adjusted for inflation has declined in Q2 and Q3. If the payroll tax cut is not renewed for 2012 (resulting in a 2% tax hike for workers, averaging about $1000 per worker), disposable income and consumer spending will be hurt early in 2012, contributing to economic weakness.
Labels:
gdp
Thursday, October 27, 2011
A First look at third quarter GDP
Today's GDP report came in as expected, with economic growth of 2.5% in the third quarter. Business investment continues to be a strength, increasing at an annualized rate of 16.3% (both equipment investment and investment in structures performed well). Consumer spending increasing at a slightly faster pace than in the second quarter (2.5%), led by a bounceback in purchases of durable goods. Inventories grew more slowly, thus subtracting about a percent from economic growth (a good sign that companies are not likely to face a need to significantly reduce inventories in the coming quarters). So far, it sounds like a pretty good report. However, real disposable income declined at a 1.7% annual rate, following a 0.6% increase in the second quarter. It was the first decline since 2009 and real income per capita is now slightly below what it was in Spring 2010. Add it up and it points toward a continuation of a sluggish recovery as consumers remained constrained by stagnant income and high debt levels.
Labels:
economic growth,
gdp
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

